Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Big Ag Lobbies to Make it Illegal to Secretly Film Animal Abuse

Activist Post

Big Agribusiness is fed up with pesky animal rights activists who expose abuses of farm animals on film.  According to the Associated Press, agriculture committees in the Iowa state government have approved a bill to outlaw secret filming of animal abuses and punish the accused with a $7500 fine and up to five years in jail.



Strangely, consumers may actually want to know if their meat is being electrocuted, beaten, or ground up alive as some recent videos have exposed.  Consumers may also want to know what the animals eat, if they ever see sunlight, if they are injected with chemicals, or even genetically cloned. Since the FDA does little to shine light on these and other concerns, activists have been the only source of this information.  Now, they will face jail time for doing so if this measure passes.

Bradley Miller, director of the Humane Farming Association, had this to say to the AP:


"They're trying to intimidate whistleblowers and put a chill on legitimate anti-cruelty investigations. Clearly the industry feels that it has something to hide or it wouldn't be going to these extreme and absurd lengths."

The excuse for the legislation given by the committee was that they were just trying to "prevent people from fraudulently seeking jobs in order to shoot videos that may give an unfair perspective on livestock operations."  This type of thing needs to be legislated in the Land of the Free with all the problems the country faces?

The Humane Society, who releases several undercover videos per year, called the legislation "draconian."  Paul Shapiro of the Humane Society said "What's needed is reform of these factory farms that will prevent cruelty to animals. What's not needed is to make factory farming cruelties more secretive."  Paul Shapiro was a contributor to the whistleblower video below:



Big agribusiness claims that these activists are radicals who want all livestock farming shut down.  On the contrary, many are just seeking a healthier product and agriculture quality reforms which reflect that.

It is unlikely that grass farmers like Joel Salatin of Polyface Farms, who raises pastured livestock, will be targeted by animal rights activists.  Salatin, famous for his appearance in the book Omnivore's Dilemma and the movie Food Inc, lets his animals live and eat as nature intended them to do.  His animals are happy while living, and far healthier when eaten.



But strangely enough Satalin has been attacked by big government regulators because he won't conform to raising animals in government-sanctioned concentration camps.  He even wrote a book about it called Everything I Want To Do is Illegal: War Stories From the Local Food Front.

This Iowa measure seems to be yet another example of big corporations using big government to criminalize those who seek to lift the veil on corrupt and abusive behavior -- or to make the consumer advocate the bad guy.  Yes, consumers may be concerned about the conditions in which their meat, poultry, and pork has been raised.  Where are they to turn for that information if the people's government is constantly in corporate cover-up mode?


13 comments:

Anonymous said...

The first couple of videos reminded me of what is being done to the ordinary citizens of the world. The last showing Satalin at least gave dignity and respect to the people the NWO that is now and is going to continue to eat.

I don't know if I will ever eat meat again because I believe the next meat eaten will be my own -- not because of necessity but because of greed and power of the New World Oder.

What the F--- happened to the Golden Rule? I guess it was for the sheeple -- not the evil that has ruled for centuries.

WAKE UP SHEEPLE!
Jan

Anonymous said...

If peaceful protest is made illegal then there's no longer any reason to remain peaceful...and you can quote me on that.

-Anonymous:-)

Anonymous said...

I am a farmer/rancher..................... and what people need to realize is that there is a big difference between a family farm and agribusiness.

I have personally been in large commercial hog barns, feedlots and poultry barns and every time I have come away with a sick feeling in the pit of my stomach. No animal deserves to live in these conditions and these intensive livestock operations exist only because profit supersedes moral and ethical obligations. There is a complete lack of empathy and concern for quality of life.

All animals that are raised under our care and control deserve a certain quality of life. It sickens me that these agribusiness operations have lasted this long. Many of them are a disgrace and a return to small family farms and organic operations would be better for the environment, better for the animals, and better for us psychologically. Remember the way we treat animals is directly reflected in how we treat other people and one needs to look no further than the state of our societies to see why the intensive livestock operations have proliferated.

Anonymous said...

Has anyone ever heard of something called property rights or liability? A farm is not a petting zoo let alone an amusement park and you just don't wander in. There are a lot of large operations that do welcome visitors and those visitors are allowed to look at whatever they want and take as many pictures as they want to.
Those farms who do not want visitors poking around do so with very good reason. They do not want to take the chance of someone getting hurt. And why is it that the minute that your not allowed to do whatever you want you start thinking something bad is happening? If you want to know where your food comes from that's fine. But if you're motives are to simply uncover some "awful truth", chances are you have no idea what your looking at anyway. And I wonder if you even want to know. Everyone wants to be a hero.

Anonymous said...

I think it's very safe to say this isn't about what spectrum you stand on in the whole Meat eating debate. Whether you are a Vegan/Vegetarian or a Meat loving omnivore. This is about Big Business and the Government constantly taking away Rights that are designated to us little by little. This is a Democracy and People Issue. Not whether killing animals and how they do it is right or wrong.

Anonymous said...

Troll alert.

Canadian Voice for Animals Foundation said...

If anyone has undercover footage and want to put it on line, send it to me and I'll say we did the undercover work...They can sue me.
Regards,
Earle
http://www.cvfaf.org/Index_1.html

Anonymous said...

Many of the animal abuse films we see are created by various groups intent on discouraging the public from eating meat. These films are supposed to be candid videos, but instead they are yellow journalism at its worst.
I live on a large farm with hundreds of cows. The cows are kept happy. An unhappy cow bellows. Our farm is very quiet.
While there are likely abuses by deranged laborers, It is not the intent of most owners to mal-treat animals. Why would they do that? To what gain? To what end.
You are being deceived because you will send some half backed charity your donation. They abuses by some of these charities is legion.

Anonymous said...

focus on the main point here:
secret filming of animal abuses and punish the accused with a $7500 fine and up to five years in jail. (this is a stupid law) This would be like making it illegal to film a rape, but letting the rapist go and prosecuting the filmer.

What about those caught on the film abusing the animals? They should at least be subject to the same or WORSE punishment.

Anonymous said...

This "law" is only for the protection of big business. Next they will be telling us, we cannot film a rape done by any politician! That would include the Congress, the Senate, and anyone who works in Washington D.C..

Russ L. Smith said...

"A righteous man regardeth the life of his beast: but the tender mercies of the wicked are cruel."
Pro 12:10

Anonymous said...

Stop eating animals, stop the killing. Love animals, don't eat them.

Anonymous said...

We are supposed to eat animals, that is why God gave them to us. If you want the evolution side of the coin, that's why we have sharp teeth. I do believe animal cruelty needs to be stopped, but there is no reason to stop eating meat. That's just stupid.

Post a Comment

ShareThis2