By B.N. Frank
Numerous issues have been identified with Electric Vehicles (EVs) in addition to battery fires (see 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6) and fires that are difficult to extinguish (see 1, 2). However, the battery fires seem to be playing the biggest role in making them less popular. Fortunately, a new tool will be available next year to firefighters fighting EV battery fires.
From Ars Technica:
New firefighting tool delivers water directly to blazing EV batteries
Technique uses less water to bring battery temps down to normal.
In April, a Tesla Model S crashed in The Woodlands, Texas, after the speeding driver failed to negotiate a turn and jumped the curb. The car then hit a drainage culvert and a raised maintenance hole before being stopped by a tree, according to an investigation report by the National Transportation Safety Board. At that point, the Tesla promptly burst into flames.
Firefighters needed four hours to douse the flames, in part because the battery kept reigniting. When the blaze was finally over, about 30,000 gallons of water had been poured on it—what the department normally uses in a month.
Electric vehicle fires aren’t common, but they’re different enough from fossil-fuel-vehicle fires that firefighters need new approaches. One firm in Europe has developed a shipping container-like box in which a blazing EV can be deposited and blasted with water from all sides. But it requires a dedicated truck, making it a costly addition for a fire department.
Next year, though, firefighters will have another option—a high-pressure nozzle that can be shoved underneath a burning vehicle to deliver water directly into the battery. Rosenbauer, an Austrian company that makes firetrucks and other equipment, says it has successfully tested the devices on a variety of battery designs, including pouch, prismatic, and cylindrical cells.
Most EVs house their batteries flat and low in the chassis, which allows for spacious interiors and a low center of gravity that benefits handling. But when a fire breaks out, there’s a lot more car between the battery and any water sprayed on top, which is the traditional technique.
The new device allows firefighters responding to battery fires to use water more efficiently and hopefully extinguish the fire faster. First, firefighters make sure nothing else is burning on the car (seats, tires, etc.). Then they slide the device under the battery before retreating about 25 feet to a control box. Finally, they activate a “piercing nozzle” which punches into the battery pack to deliver water directly to the cells.
In a preview of the technology last year, Rosenbauer said that only around 260–1,000 gallons (1,000–4,000 liters) of water are needed to bring a flaming battery pack down to a safe temperature. That’s around two orders of magnitude less than it took Texas firefighters to put out the Model S in April.
If a vehicle is on its side or roof, or if there isn’t enough clearance under the vehicle, firefighters can place the device inside the car or on the exposed undercarriage—whatever will give them safe access to the battery. The nozzle can also be left attached to the vehicle as it’s being towed away so firefighters have quick access should the battery reignite.
Other issues associated with all Electric Vehicles include
- EVs are also more expensive to maintain (see 1, 2)
- Lithium mining for EV batteries is environmentally harmful (see 1, 2)
- There are well-documented EV battery recycling obstacles
- EVs emit high levels of harmful electromagnetic radiation (see 1, 2, 3)
Nevertheless, EV proponents (including many U.S. legislators) continue to insist that EVs are what’s best for Americans and legislation has been passed to continue funding their deployment and ownership.
Activist Post reports regularly about Electric Vehicles and other unsafe technology. For more information, visit our archives and the following websites:
Provide, Protect and Profit from what’s coming! Get a free issue of Counter Markets today.